According to Football Insider’s Pete O’Rourke, Everton have decided against re-signing Richarlison during the January transfer window. The report claims the club’s board has serious doubts about the Brazilian’s desire to return to Merseyside after his summer decision.
During the summer, Richarlison reportedly opposed a proposed £35 million cash-plus-player swap involving Iliman Ndiaye and Tottenham. Alternative moves to Trabzonspor and Vasco da Gama subsequently collapsed, leaving the 29-year-old outside Roberto De Zerbi’s plans at Spurs.
Everton face a shortage of senior strikers, with Thierno Barry currently their only established option after moves for Folarin Balogun and Joshua Zirkzee fell through. Despite Richarlison’s expected availability for a reduced fee, the club reportedly have no immediate plans to pursue him.
Could Everton’s decision create a bigger attacking problem?
Everton‘s position deserves scrutiny because the club need goals and attacking depth. Walking away from a familiar forward makes sense only if Moyes can find a reliable alternative.
Richarlison’s previous spell at Goodison Park offers a strong argument for another chance. His pressing, movement around the box and ability to operate across the front three suit the qualities Moyes traditionally values. The Brazilian understands the club, the league and the demands of English football.
However, those strengths cannot erase the concerns surrounding his current situation. Richarlison has recorded zero appearances and zero minutes across all competitions in the 2026/27 season. He has also missed matchday selections while training away from Tottenham’s main first-team group.
That lack of competitive football creates a major question over his readiness. Everton cannot afford to spend scarce resources on a forward who needs time to regain sharpness, particularly with Barry carrying the senior striker burden.
The proposed £35 million swap matters because it reportedly showed Richarlison’s reluctance to return. A player who doesn’t want the move may struggle to provide the commitment Moyes needs. Dressing-room confidence matters, especially during a difficult campaign.
Wages create another obstacle. Even with a reduced transfer fee, Richarlison’s Premier League salary could place significant pressure on Everton’s finances. A cheaper deal might still carry an expensive long-term commitment.
Everton must decide whether another target can provide immediate attacking support. For now, the board’s stance reflects concerns over desire, fitness and cost rather than a lack of need for a striker.