Reports from sources like Ekrem Konur and Hotspur Lane suggest that significant doubt surrounds João Palhinha’s long-term future. This uncertainty grows as the summer transfer window gets closer. Tottenham Hotspur currently hold a £27 million option to buy the defensive midfielder. This follows his season-long loan from Bayern Munich. However, a few internal issues are making this deal look complicated.
Uncertainty Clouds João Palhinha’s Future at Tottenham Hotspur
Palhinha still shows off that signature aggression and ball-winning ability. Despite this, the club’s decision to fire Thomas Frank has totally changed their plans for new signings. Top bosses at the North London club also have some real concerns.
They aren’t sure the move makes financial sense since the player turns 31 this July. A player at that age usually has very little resale value. This goes against the long-term money strategy that the Spurs hierarchy usually sticks to.
Analysis of the Midfield Enforcer’s Situation
The Portuguese international has fit into the Spurs midfield perfectly. He has been a regular in the lineup since arriving in August 2025. He moved to London after a quiet spell at Bayern Munich. During his time in Germany, Palhinha struggled to get a regular starting spot despite moving there for big money from Fulham.
Throughout the 2025/26 season, Palhinha has averaged nearly four successful tackles every game. This shows he isn’t slowing down just yet. He even added some goals to his game this winter, scoring big goals in both the Premier League and the EFL Cup.
However, things at Spurs changed fast once Thomas Frank left. Frank was the main person pushing for an experienced player in that holding role. Without Frank’s specific tactics, the club now have to compare Palhinha’s talent against his veteran status. So, the recruitment team is stuck. Do they spend £27 million on a veteran they can’t sell later? Or do they find a younger player with similar stats?
I think Tottenham should pass on the permanent deal. Instead, they should find a younger, faster replacement. Palhinha is great at shielding the defence. However, he doesn’t move the ball forward very quickly, which slows down the counter-attacks that modern Premier League teams need.
ALSO READ: How Will Igor Tudor Lineup At Tottenham Hotspur? Tactical Analysis
Paying a high price for a player nearing the end of his career is just a short-term fix. A move like that could block younger academy players. It might also stop them from buying a 23-year-old who has a decade of football left. Bayern Munich need to drop the price below £15 million. Otherwise, the risk of a declining player outweighs the benefit of having a veteran in the room.