Tonali off after 62 minutes as Italy lose 4-1 in Brussels, days after France praise

Submitted by daniel on
Picture
Remote Image

Sandro Tonali went from praised anchor to substituted starter in three days as Belgium beat Italy 4-1. With Ipswich next for Spurs, his best position under De Zerbi is a fair question again.

Sandro Tonali’s international break ended on a sour note. He wore the number 8 shirt as Italy were beaten in League A Group A1. He was booked in first-half stoppage time and replaced on 62 minutes. Guglielmo Vicario stayed on the bench throughout.

Italy had started well. Pio Esposito scored in the 11th minute at the King Baudouin Stadium. Belgium then struck through Maxim De Cuyper, Nathan Ngoy and Jérémy Doku between the 15th and 26th minutes. Diego Moreira added a fourth late on. Esposito also had a penalty saved in stoppage time. The defeat left Italy third in their Nations League group.

The contrast with three days earlier was stark. Italy came from a goal down to beat France 3-1. Tonali sat at the centre of a three-man midfield in a 4-3-3, between Davide Frattesi and Nicolò Barella. Sky Sport Italia’s Stefano De Grandis gave him 6.5. He credited Tonali with doing his job in front of the defence, playing with determination and composure.

That position is a recent one for him with Italy. Roberto Mancini moved Tonali from a box-to-box role to the deep playmaker’s position across the last two Nations League windows, according to Tuttosport. Italy still conceded 10 goals in their six Nations League games. Six of them came in the two defeats by Belgium.

The debate carries straight over to Spurs. Tonali cost the club £100m and is central to De Zerbi’s midfield. His move from Newcastle United was announced on 6 July 2026, when he had 32 senior Italy caps.

The season started badly. Spurs failed to win any of their first six league matches, drawing three and losing three. During October, De Zerbi used Tonali just in front of the back four. Spurs beat Coventry City, won away at Chelsea and beat Crystal Palace at home. That run earned De Zerbi the Premier League Manager of the Month award. Tonali was later moved out of that role.

The momentum has since stalled. Leeds won 1-0 at Elland Road on 7 November, ending a run of four league games without defeat. Tonali was booked in the 88th minute that day.

His two nights with Italy offer contrasting evidence. The France display fits the Italian view that he does his best work at the base of midfield. The Brussels collapse showed how quickly a side can be opened up regardless. For De Zerbi, the October results remain the clearest club evidence on where Tonali has helped Spurs most.

The first chance to answer the question comes quickly. Spurs host Ipswich Town at 3pm on Saturday 21 November. The next home fixtures after that are Fulham on Thursday 3 December and Arsenal on Saturday 6 December.

Source