Former midfielder Danny Murphy remains unsure about Tottenham duo Mateus Fernandes and Sandro Tonali, expressing doubt over whether they can lead Spurs to a Champions League finish.
Mateus Fernandes and Sandro Tonali have started to settle in well in north London following their big-money moves in the summer transfer window, with the pair costing Tottenham a whopping £185 million.
While Tonali and Fernandes struggled to make an impact in their early matches, in recent outings, the Spurs duo look to have turned a corner, proving vital in Tottenham’s three-game winning run.
De Zerbi certainly trusts Tonali in the heart of midfield, with the Italian having started every game since his big-money move.
Meanwhile, Fernandes has had to bide his time, but he has started to show what he is about, with one of his better performances coming in the clash against Chelsea, when he showed his quality in and out of possession.
Danny Murphy unconvinced by Tottenham’s Sandro Tonali and Mateus Fernandes
There is every reason to be quietly optimistic about Spurs’ new-look midfield, but Danny Murphy is not convinced by Tonali and Fernandes. The former Liverpool man is unsure whether the pair will do enough together to ensure Spurs finish in the top four.
MORE SPURS STORIES
Speaking to football.london, via Pariurix.com, Murphy said: “Sandro Tonali and Mateus Fernandes both struggled at the beginning. I think Tonali in the last few weeks looks like he’s fitter, looks sharper, more confident whereas in the first three or four games I saw him, he didn’t look himself. He looked a yard off the pace.
“Now that could be for lots of reasons, which are not worth speculating, but sometimes when you go to a new club, you’re not just changing football clubs and training methods, you’re changing where you live and there’s a lot of stuff going on.
“A lot of stuff happens off the pitch that people don’t see and it can be stressful and impact your performance on it. But I think he’s looked much more like himself in the last few weeks, because he’s a good all-rounder. He’s a good footballer, he’s quick, he’s strong, he can make the odd goal, so I think he’ll be fine.
“Fernandes is a super athlete. I don’t see him as a creative player. He’s tidy on the ball and he can get about the pitch. I’ve watched him a lot and I think that he has improved, especially, in recent weeks. He’s looking more comfortable and more confident again, but I’m not quite sure what he is. Is he a holding midfielder? Well, if he is, they’re restricting his athleticism and his energy and his endurance.
“But I think the times I saw him play a bit higher and he’s not really that clever with the last little pass or comfortable and technical with his shooting and goal scoring. He will score the odd goal because he gets in good positions, but I think he’s a box to box midfielder and he will grow into that role, playing alongside maybe Tonali who’ll sit in a little bit more. And then you’ve got a Maddison or Simons or a Kudus.
“Both players have improved Spurs and have given them better options, but are they the midfield pairing that takes Spurs into a Champions League spot? I don’t think so.”
Sheringham also doubts Tonali
At the moment, Spurs are not far off the Champions League places despite sitting 11th in the Premier League table, with just four points separating them from fifth-placed Chelsea.
A Champions League finish is realistic, but the whole team will have to step up, not just Fernandes and Tonali.
Unfortunately, despite his improved performances in recent weeks, Tonali has not exactly won everyone over. Former Tottenham forward Teddy Sheringham has also expressed his doubts over the former Newcastle man.
The legendary striker believes Spurs should have gone for Elliot Anderson instead of Tonali, explaining that the Manchester City midfielder is a better all-round player.
He said: “You know, just for instance, you’ve got Tonali. It’s a good player, there’s no doubt about it. It’s a good player, a very good player. But if they’d have spent a little bit more and gone out and got Elliot Anderson and said, ‘Look, this is what we want’… You know, everything he does, he wants to be the winner. You can tell, everything he does on the football pitch, he wants to be involved. He wants to get it off the back four, he wants to go forward, he wants to tackle someone, he wants to go forward and score a goal.
“Tonali’s good. He gets about the pitch. He doesn’t get involved in everything. So if you’re going to make a statement when you’re spending that sort of money, go out and get the best. Tottenham haven’t done that.”