KMI panel reach shocking decision on Jayden Bogle red card controversy vs Tottenham

Submitted by daniel on
Picture
Remote Image

The Premier League’s Key Match Incidents panel has given its take on whether Jayden Bogle and Leeds were lucky to escape a red card during their 1-0 win over Tottenham Hotspur.

The main talking point in the days following Spurs’ loss at Elland Road was the first-half incident involving Jayden Bogle and Mathys Tel.

While coming in to challenge for the ball, the Leeds defender carelessly ran his studs down on the back of the Tottenham forward’s ankle, which meant that the Frenchman could play no further part in the game.

Even more concerningly for the Lilywhites, reports indicate that Tel could now face a long period on the treatment table, with Spurs fans waiting for Roberto De Zerbi’s pre-match press conference on Friday to find out more about the 21-year-old’s injury.

The on-field referee, John Brooks, did not even deem Bogle’s challenge worthy of a booking, and VAR, Tony Harrington, refused to intervene, despite watching replays of the incident for four minutes as the Spurs forward was receiving treatment.

KMI panel say correct decision was reached despite Tottenham complaints

The KMI panel’s review of all incidents across matchweek 10 has now been released, and Tottenham fans will be left surprised by the verdict.

MORE SPURS STORIES

The panel consists of five former Premier League officials, who all vote on whether each controversial decision made across the Premier League weekend is correct.

It was a split verdict on Bogle’s tackle, with the panel voting 3-2 that the decision not to award the Leeds right-back a red card was the correct one.

The document reads: “This was a split decision with the majority supporting the referee’s on-field call of no red card. The panel considered this to be a clear foul but the majority felt Bogle was looking to challenge with his right leg and his left leg came down on the back of Tel’s ankle without the speed, force or intensity to be serious foul play.

“They felt that the contact made was very clearly reckless, but below the threshold for a red card. Two Panellists felt that the challenge was sufficiently dangerous to merit a red card.”

What particularly angered Roberto De Zerbi’s side was the fact that the VAR did not ask the referee to rewatch the challenge.

In fact, Spurs even complained to the officiating body Pro Ref about VAR’s decision and sought clarification on why Harrington did not urge Brooks to rewatch the challenge.

However, the KMI panel also voted 3-2 that Harrington’s decision was correct as the challenge did not meet the threshold for an obvious error.

The document adds: “The non-VAR intervention was also supported, 3:2, on the basis that the majority considered the challenge to be reckless, therefore not a clear and obvious error.”

Several former referees believe Bogle should have seen red against Spurs

The opinion of the panel contrasts with that of several former PMGOL officials, who have all unanimously suggested that Bogle’s challenge on Tel was red card worthy.

That includes former Premier League referee Mike Dean, who was adamant during the game that it was a clear red card, stating:

Dean said: “It is 100 per cent a red, he has caught him right down the back of the Achilles. It is not a good tackle at all. I would be astounded if John Brooks is not sent to the screen.”

Former assistant referee Darren Cann also stated that Bogle was lucky to not be sent off, suggesting that the challenge met the criteria for clear foul play.

Additionally, speaking to Sky Sports’ Ref Watch segment, Dermot Gallagher felt that the challenge was high enough to warrant a red card.

Gallagher said: “I think it is a red card, he is extremely lucky, he catches him across the Achilles, high, we have this directive of ‘above the ankle, or Achilles’ and that falls under that line. We saw it with Ryan Sessegnon a few weeks ago with a similar tackle and Mateta last week.”

Source