Report: Tottenham Hotspur ‘open’ to signing former Premier League striker
Tottenham Consider Ivan Toney Move As January Window Looms
Tottenham’s search for a decisive striker has accelerated and with a second major source now confirming their information, the prospect of Ivan Toney returning to the Premier League in January has gained significant traction. The club’s current attacking return, or lack of it, underscores why such a move is being explored with urgency.
Spurs are operating without a clear focal point. Their top scorer so far is centre back Micky van de Ven with six goals in all competitions, a statistic that speaks volumes about the imbalance in their forward line. Randal Kolo Muani has yet to find the net on loan, Dominic Solanke is hampered by an ankle issue, Mathys Tel remains raw, and Richarlison continues to fluctuate.
TEAMtalk revealed earlier this week that Thomas Frank has already held direct talks with Toney, a detail later echoed by talkSPORT. As the report stated, Frank would be open to bringing him back to the Premier League and the player is receptive. Spurs, according to TEAMtalk sources, are currently leading the race.
Toney Dynamics And Tottenham’s Striking Puzzle
The strongest supporting view came from talkSPORT’s chief reporter, Alex Crook, who told the station, “I keep coming back to Ivan Toney for Tottenham. You look at what he did with Thomas Frank at Brentford. I think he’d like to come back to the Premier League, obviously financially it might be a difficult deal, but that just looks a perfect fit to me for Spurs either in January or next summer.”
Toney scored 20 Premier League goals in his final season under Frank at Brentford, a period that showcased his power, movement, and penalty box instinct. His move to Al Ahli in the summer of 2024 offered financial benefits, but the competitive drop off has clearly impacted his international prospects. His omission from Thomas Tuchel’s latest England squad is an important detail. Spurs will know that Toney has strong incentive to come back to England if he wants to secure a World Cup spot.
Market Realities And Viable Routes
TEAMtalk sources have indicated that Spurs regard Toney as the ideal short term solution, although a permanent move mid season is unlikely. A January fee of £30 million has discouraged buyers and the structure of his Saudi contract complicates any early termination due to a significant tax liability.
The most credible arrangement is a loan or a loan with obligation to buy, a structure that protects Al Ahli’s investment yet offers Spurs the opportunity to bring in a proven striker. It also helps Tottenham prepare for potential exits, particularly Richarlison, who faces an uncertain future amid interest from Everton.
There are further squad developments. Spurs have added a centre back with a similar profile to Van de Ven to their shortlist and are monitoring Wolves midfielder Joao Gomes, who could move if his side face relegation pressure. Academy forward Dane Scarlett is also expected to be integrated more frequently as the club plans ahead.
Frank, Spurs And How This Might Unfold
The appeal of a Frank and Toney reunion is clear. Their tactical chemistry was proven at Brentford, and Spurs would gain a striker who understands both the tempo and physicality of Premier League football. Toney, meanwhile, gains a platform to revive his international ambition.
Our View – EPL Index Analysis
For Tottenham, this report reflects both hope and hesitation. The squad has reached a stage where the lack of a reliable, clinical striker is affecting momentum and results, and many fans believe pursuing Ivan Toney is not only logical but overdue. Spurs have changed under the current regime, becoming more aggressive in possession and more structured in transition, yet the absence of a dependable finisher continues to stand out. Supporters would argue that Toney, with his Premier League pedigree and physical presence, fits the profile of a number nine who can immediately elevate the attack.
Fans remember clearly how ruthless Toney was with Brentford, and the thought of him working within Tottenham’s current system generates cautious optimism. There is acknowledgement that the financial and contractual complications are real, but supporters tend to focus on the outcome rather than the negotiation details. The idea of a loan with obligation to buy appears sensible and allows Spurs to assess how quickly he adapts.
Some Tottenham fans are sceptical about taking a player who has been outside Europe’s top leagues, but the consensus is that his hunger to return to England and reclaim a place in the national team could drive him to deliver quickly. There is also awareness that Richarlison’s inconsistency continues to hold the team back, and this move could be the moment Spurs reset their forward line properly.
The overarching opinion is simple. Spurs need a striker with presence, maturity and proven output, and Toney fits that template far better than the current options. The feeling is one of cautious expectation, curiosity about the loan structure, and a strong belief that if this deal happens, Spurs could shift up a gear in the second half of the season.