Tottenham squad ladder: Tel, Robertson and Tonali fly up our ranking, but it’s bad news for Bentancur

Submitted by daniel on
Picture
Remote Image

Welcome back to the second edition of Tottenham Hotspur’s squad ladder, a series from The Athletic that provides a monthly assessment of each player’s performance over the season.

Each player will be assessed on their availability, current impact and potential to help the team in the coming weeks. Should one player be thrust into a more central role, expect their ranking to rise accordingly, and vice versa. Those who have yet to feature for Spurs are excluded from our consideration, though we will exercise editorial discretion to decide whether to include players who have seen limited game time due to injuries, managerial decisions, or other reasons.

Since we did it last, Spurs have rescued a point at Old Trafford in second-half stoppage time with 10 men, enjoyed their first three-game winning streak since February 2025, and have been eased down from cloud nine with a narrow 1-0 defeat away at Leeds United. Over that period, a couple of big-money signings have made an equivalent impression, an early-season standout has fallen down the pecking order, and one beloved academy youngster has announced himself as a major talent with a breathtaking cameo from the bench.

Here, The Athletic’s Elias Burke provides the analysis.

A steady pair of hands with Premier League experience, he should make a capable deputy for Antonin Kinsky in all areas other than distribution.

A club stalwart and leadership figure who somehow has two goals to his name this season. May not start another game this season or reach 10 appearances across all competitions, but remains important in the dressing room as team captain.

An outstanding talent who is still finding his feet after missing 526 days with a complicated patella injury. A delight to see him back on the pitch, and it would have been an early contender for moment-of-the-season had his curling effort not been excellently saved by Dean Henderson against Crystal Palace last month, but Kulusevski is still a considerable way off being fully match fit. Could he provide competition for Dominic Solanke and Omar Marmoush as a No 9?

Tosin has been namechecked as a leader by Roberto De Zerbi, suggesting he has already made his mark on the squad after arriving on deadline day from Chelsea. Impressed in the 3-1 win over Coventry, starting as a left centre-back, suggesting he would be up to the task in the league should Jan Paul van Hecke suffer an injury or drop off in form.

The Sweden international tied his long-term future to north London in September with a new contract, but then sustained an injury in last month’s draw with Manchester United and has been unavailable since. De Zerbi has faith in Bergvall, evidenced by his decision to start him at the base of midfield at Old Trafford, but he faces stiff competition for minutes.

De Zerbi called Williams-Barnett’s number at Elland Road, hoping the teenage sensation could inspire a late comeback after going 1-0 down. Should Mykhailo Mudryk and Mathys Tel be sidelined for a period, and Savio takes a couple of weeks to find match fitness after missing more than a month, Williams-Barnett may play a substantial role over the next couple of months.

Nineteenth is perhaps a couple of places higher than his experience and pedigree merit, with barely more than 10 minutes of Premier League football under his belt, but Williams-Barnett could become a much more important player than most envisioned as we enter the festive season. The 18-year-old came off the bench to make an electric Premier League debut in the 2-0 win at home to Palace, creating a golden chance for Mohammed Kudus to score minutes after his introduction.

A game-changer for Tottenham when fit and available, but Udogie’s name listed on the team sheet is becoming more and more infrequent. Udogie has started just two league games for Spurs this term, and has played just 19 per cent of available minutes. De Zerbi described his fitness record as “problematic” in a pre-match press conference, suggesting that he is becoming frustrated with the 23-year-old’s inability to stay off the physio’s bench.

Very impressive in the 1-1 draw at Old Trafford, not so much in the 3-0 away defeat to Brentford on the opening day. Like Van Hecke, Senesi is considered among the league’s best ball-playing centre-backs, but is similarly lacking in pace and athleticism — which could be problematic should they be paired together more consistently. A deep run in the FA Cup should provide a platform for the Argentina international to play more regularly.

Retains an important role as a rotational player under De Zerbi after being integral in last season’s successful bid to stave off relegation. Can play as a No 8 and 10, and De Zerbi appreciates his eye for goal and hard work off the ball, particularly away from home. Was unlucky not to add his third goal of the season with a sweet strike from distance that whistled just wide of the post at Elland Road.

Probably Tottenham’s standout player before a petulant red card at Old Trafford led to Spurs’ best run in the Premier League for 18 months. Bentancur is highly rated by De Zerbi and should serve as a capable alternative to Mateus Fernandes as a No 6 and to Sandro Tonali as a No 8, particularly when Tottenham are ahead in games and want to retain possession.

His goal in the win against Coventry was an excellently taken finish from outside the box and his desire to shoot from all angles adds a potentially important dimension to a Spurs attack short on goals, but he must improve his hold-up play and conversion rate within 18 yards if he is to provide effective competition for Solanke as the No 9.

Still, Marmoush’s versatility as a left-winger, striker, and second striker is appreciated by De Zerbi and will be invaluable should Tottenham qualify for European competition next season.

A prodigiously gifted dribbler and take-on machine without the final-third production to show for it. We’ll have a better idea whether Savio’s lack of goals and assists is down to him or whether it’s the inability of Tottenham’s forwards to finish chances when he returns after the international break from an injury that has sidelined him since mid-October.

Dubbed the world’s best in his position by De Zerbi, the main reason Porro is 14th is due to his patchy injury record this term. Demonstrated his attacking quality after replacing Archie Gray at half-time in the 2-0 win against Palace, naturally slotting into the right half-space position that De Zerbi directs the right-back to occupy in possession. Did not have his best game at Elland Road, but he should rise quickly on this list with a run of consistent starts.

After missing a couple of excellent opportunities to score at Old Trafford, Solanke got his first of the season in a slightly fortuitous manner to level in stoppage time — but it has not turned out to be the turning point many had hoped it would be. There have been glimpses of how his experience and presence as a focal point could elevate the team under De Zerbi, but he continues to appear short of his physical best after an injury-ravaged couple of years in north London, despite featuring in every game this term.

Has an X factor in the final third that Spurs desperately miss when he’s unavailable, justifying his spot inside the top 10. Minor niggles have limited him to just one start this season, where he opened the scoring with a stunning curling effort from outside the box in the 3-1 win against Coventry, the club where he came through as a youngster. Would surely surge up the rankings if he can stay fit, but that’s turning into a big if.

Hungry to prove he should retain his spot in the starting line-up after earning his place with an outstanding solo goal to seal last month’s win at Stamford Bridge. Should he start scoring and assisting consistently, Tel could be in line for a debut call-up for the France senior national team after being involved in Zinedine Zidane’s provisional long. list for the November internationals, provided the ankle injury he sustained at Elland Road is not too serious.

Tottenham’s Mr Versatile and a universally popular character. Gray sees himself as a midfielder, but within De Zerbi’s system, he has proven himself best suited to a right-back role, standing in for Porro, who has struggled with minor injuries. He did however leave Noah Okafor free to roam into the box to score the winner in the 1-0 defeat to his old club.

Proving a very sensible bit of free-agent business as an experienced leader and dependable character, while retaining a wicked delivery from open play and set pieces. May not be as athletically dynamic as he was in his prime, but Robertson will play a lot of football this season owing to Udogie’s injury record.

It took a few weeks for Kudus to warm up after returning from a hamstring injury that sidelined him since January, but he’s edging closer to his best. He was integral in Spurs’ historic 2-0 win away at Chelsea in October, providing a reliable outlet for defenders and the goalkeeper with his touch, strength and speed. Awaiting his first goal of the season after spurning a couple of good opportunities in recent weeks. Questionable decision-making and profligacy in the final third are stopping him from becoming a star.

He starred in Tottenham’s 2-0 win over Crystal Palace on Halloween, scoring the crucial second and keeping a clean sheet as Spurs won back-to-back home games for the first time since November 2024. One of the league’s leading passers from the back line, but prone to the occasional lapse in concentration and can be exposed for pace in De Zerbi’s high line.

In pre-season, De Zerbi said Kinsky has “all the qualities to become one of the best” due to his character and quality as a distributor. There have been a couple of shaky moments in his first period as Spurs’ undisputed No 1, but his ability to pass at short, medium and long distances to break through the opposition press means he remains on track to becoming an established Premier League starter. Was Tottenham’s standout performer in the 1-0 defeat to Leeds, making an outstanding save from Sean Longstaff.

Looked a little uncomfortable starting the season as a No 10 but has delivered on his potential since being moved deeper in midfield. While De Zerbi was keen to play down the Luka Modric comparisons when asked about them before the win against Palace, it’s not hard to envision a reality where he is recognised among the best deep-lying playmakers in the league — if he is not there already.

It’s looking like £100million well spent for Tottenham’s irreplaceable do-it-all midfielder. He started the season slowly but has gradually improved as he’s built match fitness through the weeks and months. He was outstanding through Tottenham’s three-game winning run before the defeat at Leeds, but he struggled to find a similar influence in the defeat at Elland Road. He was in with a shout for the top spot, but Micky van de Ven’s consistency narrowly wins out.

Van de Ven has been consistently excellent defensively since De Zerbi became Tottenham head coach on the last day of March, and he appears to be improving. Under the Italian, Van de Ven has made considerable strides as a ball-player and leader, appearing to thrive with the new responsibility of being club captain. Should be targeting five or more goals this season after proving his worth as a threat from set-pieces last term.

How did The Athletic reach this conclusion?

The top five players were fairly easy to select, but I found myself deliberating over the order. In the end, there may have been some recency bias, with Kinsky’s performance at Elland Road pushing him ahead of Van Hecke, who I had in fourth after scoring the week before.

While Maddison’s penchant for picking up small niggles is a considerable concern, he remains so important to the team that his position on the ladder is outsized relative to his influence this term. Perhaps a similar argument could be made for Udogie, who raises the team’s level when he plays, but Robertson provides a more-than-capable deputy, which Spurs do not seem to have for Maddison. Maybe that player will turn out to be Williams-Barnett, who, somewhat shockingly, ranks higher than Bergvall and Kulusevski.

Who didn’t make the ladder?

The most notable omission is Mudryk (previously 22nd), who remains unavailable after picking up an ankle injury in a short cameo from the bench in the 0-0 draw at Nottingham Forest, his first competitive minutes since November 2024. Who knows if we will see him again in a Tottenham shirt. Backup goalkeepers and academy graduates who have made the matchday squad but have not featured have also been left out.

Who will fly up the ladder next month?

Savio